Racine County May Release Reports From Probe Sparked by Deputy’s Arrest

4 min read

RACINE COUNTY, Wis. — The Racine County Board of Supervisors is expected to consider on Dec. 8 whether to release two redacted reports from an independent investigation launched after the arrest of former Racine County sheriff’s deputy Preston Kite. The reports helped form the basis for discipline against Sheriff’s Office Capt. Cary Madrigal over how she responded to allegations that another deputy received an inappropriate photo from Kite.

The board’s Committee of the Whole met in closed session Tuesday, Nov. 17, to consult with legal counsel about the independent review and discuss a pending personnel matter involving a Sheriff’s Office employee. After returning to open session, supervisors voted to direct the county’s corporation counsel to draft a resolution that would waive attorney-client privilege for the two reports and authorize their release with redactions. The County Board is scheduled to consider the resolution Dec. 8.

Why Racine County hired outside investigators

In early 2024, the Racine County Sheriff’s Office hired the law firm Crivello, Nichols & Hall to examine allegations of misconduct or policy violations that surfaced in connection with Kite’s arrest. After news of the arrest, the Sheriff’s Office received tips about Kite’s conduct both on and off the job.

County Corporation Counsel Michael Lanzdorf said in a Nov. 13 memo that outside counsel was brought in to conduct an independent review, recommend corrective action and advise the county on potential litigation. The Kenosha County Sheriff’s Department conducted the separate criminal investigation because Kite worked for Racine County. That case led to Kite’s conviction and incarceration.

The law firm’s review lasted roughly 12 months. Investigators reviewed records and interviewed at least 13 witnesses who participated voluntarily and held varying roles in the Sheriff’s Office and courts. They asked what witnesses knew firsthand about Kite, what they had heard from others and how misconduct was reported and handled inside the Sheriff’s Office.

What the review found and recommended

According to Lanzdorf’s memo, the firm found no evidence of widespread misconduct or sexual harassment within the Sheriff’s Office. It recommended reviewing how staff and supervisors identify and report sexual harassment, considering additional training and creating a way for employees to report concerns anonymously.

The firm also recommended a personnel investigation into Madrigal’s response to allegations that another deputy received inappropriate photos from Kite. The findings and recommendations specific to Madrigal became the basis for a disciplinary complaint within the Sheriff’s Office.

When the county received public records requests for Madrigal’s disciplinary file, its legal office determined that the complaint could be disclosed. The complaint included detailed excerpts from the independent review about Madrigal. A legal challenge sought to block access to those records, and a Racine County Circuit Court order dated May 22 cleared the way for their release.

Which reports could be released

The law firm produced three reports. Two were dated Dec. 2, 2024, and the third, dated Feb. 4, 2025, was a brief follow-up addressing a discrepancy in the timeline. The proposed resolution covers two reports addressed to the county’s human resources director, one from December and the February follow-up.

Lanzdorf said the underlying reports contain confidential legal advice and information from witnesses who participated voluntarily. He raised concerns about employee privacy, possible retaliation and whether employees would come forward in future investigations if their accounts could become public. Board Chairman Tom Kramer said supervisors must weigh those concerns alongside the county’s commitment to transparency and accountability.

The Nov. 17 vote authorized drafting the resolution. The decision on whether to release the two redacted reports is scheduled for Dec. 8.


Stay tuned to Kenosha County Scanner for police, fire, EMS activity, local news, and weather.

You May Also Like

More From Author

+ There are no comments

Add yours